While I think the Ruger is ok, I prefer the older buckmark over them. My favorite by far is the Colt Woodsman Match 2nd series with the 4 1/2 barrel. I like the standard 4 1/2 inch barrel, which is a dream to carry, but the match does edge it out when the competition is involved. The mag release behind the trigger guard makes for easy mag changes, and the mags have a comfortable thumb knob for easy reloading.