Since we are taking it off topic, I think I'd take a newer model over the old model any day, as I doubt the size difference affects practicality, and i'd take a 4.0 "alpha" platform over the older version any day. Add to that the options with the off road or Pro4x model, and it's not even a fair comparison. So no, the new Xterras are not just over grown luxury wagons. With all that said, I've never even owned an Xterra, just wanted one and researched, and test drove them quite a bit.