Which shingle?

[Irving]

Despite inspecting roofs for a living, I'm unfamiliar with different roof brands. Large enough hail will destroy anything. Presidential is a waste of material. Builder's grade is garbage. I've never even heard of a roof being replaced under warranty.

I know that isn't as helpful as you'd like. I assume you're looking at some sort of 30-year laminate/architectural?

[Fentonite]

I had the certainteed presidential TL pit on last year and like the relief between the shingles

I'll take a look at that one too

Despite inspecting roofs for a living, I'm unfamiliar with different roof brands. Large enough hail will destroy anything. Presidential is a waste of material. Builder's grade is garbage. I've never even heard of a roof being replaced under warranty.

I know that isn't as helpful as you'd like. I assume you're looking at some sort of 30-year laminate/architectural?

Yeah, looking at architectural shingles, look nicer than 3-tab. The warranties of all of them seem exaggerated when I read the fine print.