Thanks for the all the great recommendations, guys!

I went by Tanglewood Archery this weekend; bit hard to find, actually had to turn on the GPS. The owner was a great guy, talked with me for a bit, measured my draw length and fitted me for a bow, then took me into their indoor range and taught me to shoot it. I think he earned a customer with his great level of service (exactly what I was looking for), but I didn't realize how much it was going to cost to get into. I try not to buy anything I can't pay cash for, so I'll have to sock away a few dollars out of the gun budget before I can get away with dropping that kind of coin. It probably doesn't help that I went straight from there to Sportsman's and bought a new CCW.