Cheap Comms - Baofeng Radios

[Grant H.]

My sincerest apologies for not having the write up finished yet. I have had a few unexpected tasks thrown at me at work, and have been buried... I will get this up as quickly as possible.

Anyone ever tried the Radioddity GA-5S radio? I've got a UV5RA, was thinking of picking up a second, and saw that one. Looks a higher powered Baefeng clone.

I haven't but I have a radioddity truck radio on the way, so I will have an idea of what I think of something from them. Overall internet reaction seems positive to their private labeled radios.

Will this Chirrp program work with my Yaesu FT-50R with the MARS/CAP mod? I programmed it manually ages ago and suspect a lot has changed. Would be nice to update without the brainhurt. I'll pick up a couple Baefengs too.

Per this, yes. I haven't programmed mine with Chirp yet.

https://chirp.danplanet.com/projects/chirp/wiki/Home

I have considered getting something like this for my RZR for comms when riding. Should I just get the handheld?

https://www.ebay.com/itm/QYT-KT-8900...S/142247329890

I have one of these on the way for a repeater build and I can give you my thoughts once I get it (supposed to be delivered 7/15).

These truck radios, with the higher TX power and a good whip (the one I linked comes with a whip antenna) will cover a LOT more distance than a handheld.

As a non radio person, would these with updated antenna work for talking between say Longmont and Westminster off repeaters or whatever? Dad has his ham licence and some equipment. Figured these might be fun for him to play with as a gift and possibly get setup to call each other with.

With repeaters? Yep. Direct? Likely not. I can hit the BARC repeater at NCAR from the basement of my house in SE Longmont, but that's a very nice set of antennas, filters, and radios (been there when I was in BARC Jr, and got to "help" tune a new filter that was installed).

I was taught to usually figure 1 watt per mile of communications without using repeaters. (Line of site, no obstacles) If mountain top to mountain top, you can get some distance. Bigger and better antennas help.

That's a pretty good rule of thumb, but it is conservative, as evidenced by my ability to hit and use the BARC repeater at NCAR from my house. Google earth says that is 14 miles. This is with my uv-5r+ and either the 8" or 15" Nagoya/Radioddity antennas.

The 2 meter Ham band is better (140MHz) with terrain and obstacles, because it will bend and push through better than the 400MHz of the 70cm Ham band and the FRS band. The FRS/GMRS/70cm band is WAYYY better than the modern 900MHz digital radios used by LE/FD/EMS, unless you have a trunked repeater setup like they do. Handheld to handheld will blow in the 900MHz band.

Basically, the lower the frequency, the better it will perform over distance. Think about FM radio stations (80-100MHz) vs AM radio stations (.5-1.7MHz). AM covers so much more ground, because it has a frequency that is so much lower. AM and FM stations are generally pretty similar in output power.

For real radio.

I'm sure not getting 10 miles from the cheap illegal chinese linear amp I have on my CB. ;-)

Make sure your radio output is in line with the expected input of the amp. If you are over/under driving the amp, it won't be happy, and won't play nice.

Would these radios be a good buy for someone who doesn't know anything about radio or HAM, but is interested in getting the license?

Also, I assume you can use these to talk to people using other brands of radio, as long as they're on the same band?

Yes, and yes. The only caveat to talking to other radios is that some FRS radios can run "security" to make your conversations private, so if others are using that, you can't hear what they are saying, just noise.