I have seen/experienced this 1st hand many times in different rifles using Nosler bullets. I swore them off many years ago and haven't used them since. I do know that many people love Nosler bullets and have great results, particularly the ballistic tip bullets.
BTW MSRP on Nosler 168 Match ammo is $27/box per their web site. If someone is banging you for $35 you need to quit buying from them.

I too have had great luck with the accuracy of Federal Match Ammo, but don't like how dirty Federal ammo shoots. It gets guns dirty fast.
I've heard great things also about Black Hills, but no 1st hand experience.

If you can't roll your own and want to shoot on a budget:
I perfer Hornady Match (both A-Max and HPBT) (168 grain)
If accuracy is priority over price: (around $50/box)
Laupua Scenar 167 grain HPBT- Scarey accurate in everything
A quality rifle like a 5R will group this ammo under 1" at 300 yards.