Thats is what's odd. The first switch is getting 85 volts, the second is at 121. Unless I'm completely clueless, which is possible. I just try not to kill myself with electricity. I'll show the meter readings in a min to clarify
I edited my post to include this :
Also, you need a grounding jumper to each switch, that is what those crusty green screws on the bottom of each switch are for.